⏱️ 20 min. estimated read time

Did a friend forward you this email? Sign up here so you get them all!

Good morning Summer pumpkins. Dorothy here.

Happy Saturday! Grab your favourite hot drink ☕, it’s Plentiful time.

Is it still Summer where you are? Because from my window, it is so so ☁️. School started on 17 August for my son and the weather turned to shit approximately eleven minutes later. Back to school plus back to rain has made these last few days feel more like Blue Monday than August. The rain is welcome, obviously, and I am fairly sure it will soon be offensive to complain about it at all, given the heat and the fires and everything that came with them. But I am a summer girl.

Luckily, I found the sun somewhere else, because writing this newsletter is still one of my favourite parts of the week.

There is a funny Dutch word for Summer news content: Komkommertijd. Or cucumber time. It is what the Dutch call the weeks when nothing happens and the news runs out of news. Man finds oddly shaped potato. Here are seventeen photographs of a duck. The Germans call it Sauregurkenzeit, pickled cucumber time. The French call it la saison des marronniers, conker season, because the same tired stories come round every year like falling chestnuts.

And here is the part I love, because it turns out to be a money story. The English had it first. A dictionary of thieves' slang from 1700 defines cucumber time as "Taylers Holiday, when they have leave to Play, and Cucumbers are in season." Tailors had no work all summer. As the Pall Mall Gazette put it in 1867: when cucumbers are in, the gentry are out of town. An entire trade's income vanished every year, on schedule, because its customers went on holiday.

At Plentiful however, no time for cucumbers, ducks, potatoes, and fillers. Golden hour all the way through.

So here is what I have for you this week, and it is really about one idea: getting things wrong on purpose.

Summer Edition #7: The failure issue

One question, one tap: thirty seconds, and your answer decides what we build first in September.

The Feature: Failing Forward. What your brain (and your money) have in common

Your homework: four exercises for failing usefully. One for before, one for during, one for after, one for keeps.

Trailblazers Past and Present: she built the pension floor in 1935 and you have probably never heard her name.

Cahier de vacances: the Plentiful summer quiz. Ten questions, seven editions, no cheating.

Second to last of the season. Laura closes us out next Saturday.

As always, share the love 💗 and forward this to the strong women in your life.

~ D 🍭

PS: Every section stands on its own so snack or feast, in any order, at your own pace.

One question, One tap

Pssst, don’t skip this:

We asked you twice this summer to fill in a survey and got almost nothing back. Which is fair. That tells us we asked badly, not that you do not care, and I would rather say that out loud than send you the same form a third time and hope.

So. One question, and you answer it by clicking. No form, no scrolling but only 1 possible answer. Pick the hottest!

Wanted to select more than one? Yeah, I know, me too. Good thing you can paste your frustration in the comments. 😆

The feature

Failing Forward: What your brain (and your money) have in common

Someone recently told me I was afraid of failure. My first reaction was extreme doubt. Me? I have built a business from nothing, moved countries, changed careers five times, said yes to people and adventures I knew nothing about. Afraid of failure is not the story I tell about myself. It is not the story my friends would tell either.

But the comment stuck, the way the annoying ones always do, especially the ones you worry might be true. So I dug. That is what I do when something in me resists an idea. I do not let it go until I understand why it is there. And because I am quite obsessed with personal growth, and growth in general, I think of myself as a video game. Every piece of self-awareness I unlock is a new level, and a way to reach my goals faster and far more fluidly.

I grew up in France, in a school system that was not exactly failure friendly, and I doubt it has changed much. My mother did not love grades below seven out of ten, and seven was already considered mediocre. In class, I was the kid who would not raise her hand until she had the perfect sentence ready in her head. Word for word. No room for stumbling. Kids were unforgiving, and so were some teachers. Sadly, by the time the sentence was ready, the moment had usually passed and someone else had answered.

Here is the strange part. I love being on stage. Put a microphone in my hand and an audience in front of me and I am at ease. But ask me to raise my hand from within that same audience, to speak up unprepared, and something in me still tightens. I sweat. My heart picks up. I force myself to do it more now than I ever used to, because I know, logically, that nothing bad will happen. But the feeling is still there, decades later, tracing back to an old classroom.

That gap between the two, the ease on stage and the dread of the raised hand, says everything. The stage is rehearsed. Controlled. It proves I am good at something I have already mastered. The raised hand is the opposite. It is the risk of being wrong in real time, in front of people, with nothing to hide behind.

Watch a child learn to walk and you will not see a single one of them get discouraged after the first fall. They fall, they get up, they fall again, and somewhere between fall two hundred and fall two hundred and one, they are walking. My own son does the same thing on his bike, with a ball, with a pen he is learning to hold. He falls, and picks it up, and goes again, almost like nothing happened. Watching him do this so naturally makes me realise how far most of us have drifted from our own most basic instinct.

❝

Mistakes are not the exception to learning. They are the method.

Because none of us learn to walk without falling. None of us learn a handstand without landing on our backs first. Nobody becomes a parent without getting it wrong more times than they would like to admit. Nobody becomes a great leader without a long trail of mistakes behind them. We do not build a new version of ourselves, a new career, a new life, without a few wrong turns (and a few girlfriends and boyfriends) along the way. Mistakes are not the exception to learning. They are the method. It is how you learned to ride a bike, how you learned to swim, how I have slowly become a slightly better human, one dig at a time. And it is going to be exactly the same for your financial journey.

I write about this today because I had yet another conversation with a formidable young woman who opened with a statement I have heard from so many of you: I do not want to make mistakes. Well, lady, buckle up. I went down a neuroscience rabbit hole this summer, and failure IS the thing that will make you better with money, provided a few things happen along the way.

I have been reading Carol Dweck's Mindset lately, and it gave language to something I had felt for years without naming it. She describes two worlds. In one, the fixed world, success means proving that you are already smart, already talented, already enough. In the other, the growth world, success means stretching yourself into something new. Effort is not a sign that you are not naturally good at something, effort is the thing that makes you good at it. My classroom self, the one waiting for the perfect sentence, was operating entirely inside the fixed world. Raising an unprepared hand was not a learning opportunity to her, it was a referendum on her worth. Ouch. Needless to say, I do not like being in the fixed world.

Here is where it gets interesting, because neuroscience backs this up almost exactly. Andrew Huberman, the now somewhat famous Stanford professor turned podcast superstar, has spent years studying learning and neuroplasticity, and he explains that making an error is not a glitch in the learning process, it is the trigger for it. When you get something right, your brain has no particular reason to take notice. When you get something wrong, your brain releases the neurotransmitters, dopamine among them, that drive it to adapt. Researchers have even found that an error rate of around fifteen percent may be close to optimal for learning. You are meant to get it wrong, regularly, on purpose almost, because that is the signal your brain is waiting for.

What feels like stress in that moment, the sweat, the tightening, is not your brain failing you. It is your brain paying closer attention than it does when things go smoothly. Which means the raised hand, the one that still makes me sweat all these years later, was never a malfunction. It was exactly the kind of moment that was supposed to make me sharper. Nobody told me that at nine years old in a French classroom. Damn.

So how do you move from one world to the other, from fixed to growth, from waiting for the perfect sentence to just saying something? Not by convincing yourself you are suddenly fearless. It is smaller than that, more mechanical. You notice the fixed mindset voice, the one demanding perfection before you are allowed to try, and you act against it anyway, in small doses, on purpose. That is what forcing my hand up now, sweat and all, actually is. It is a small, survivable exposure to being wrong, repeated enough times that it stops feeling like danger and starts feeling like data.

❝

What she wanted was not really a strategy. It was a guarantee against ever being wrong.

Last Sunday I was at a business bootcamp run by a friend, doing a mock finance call with a young woman in her twenties. She wanted to get better with money, to start investing, and she kept circling back to one word: safe. She wanted it safe. She did not want to lose anything. And in the same breath, she mentioned she was curious about crypto and forex. I sat with that for a second, because those two things do not really belong in the same sentence. What she wanted was not really a strategy, it was a guarantee against ever being wrong.

She is twenty two. At twenty two I knew far less about money than she already does, so credit where it is due. But that need for a guarantee, that instinct to avoid loss above almost everything else, is not hers alone. I hear it constantly, from women in Ghana, in France, across North America and Asia. Different backgrounds, different currencies, same underlying script. Somewhere along the way, most of us were taught that being wrong is dangerous rather than useful. Nobody handed us the fifteen percent rule.

But failing is not the opposite of a sound financial life. Obviously. It is the mechanism behind one. The first investment you get wrong will teach you more than the ten you get comfortably right. The point is not to chase certainty, because certainty does not exist in markets any more than it existed in my classroom. The point is to make your failures small enough to survive and frequent enough to learn from, the same way you learned to walk, to swim, to ride a bike.

And here is the part that matters MOST, which is why this piece comes with homework attached.

Failing does not teach you anything. Not on its own.

Manu Kapur, whose book is called Productive Failure, has spent his career at ETH Zurich on exactly this, and he separates productive failure from unproductive failure. The thing that separates them is not the failure. Both groups fail. What matters is what happens next: whether you go back over it and make sense of what actually occurred. Struggle followed by sense-making is where the learning lives. Struggle on its own is just struggle, and most of us are extremely well practised at that part. How we react to it, and what we do with it, is what matters. Think of all the athletes in the world who practise for thousands of hours, fail on the day of the competition, and get back to it anyway. I always think there is a lot to learn from these people.

Which is annoying, because the sense-making is the bit we skip. We fail, we feel bad about it, we move on quickly so we do not have to look. And then we wonder why the same thing keeps happening.

But you are brave. You have done difficult things, scary things. Managing your money better is no different. I promise.

And to be practical about it, I went looking for actual methods. Simple exercises.

Here are four, and none of them takes longer than twenty minutes.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Plentiful.money to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Reply

Avatar

or to participate