⏱️ 22 min. estimated read time

Did a friend forward you this email? Sign up here so you get them all!

Hi everyone. Laura here.

Happy Saturday morning. I just got back from a week at the beach, and as I said in a previous edition, that’s my happy place.

However, this year? It was perhaps the rainiest week I’ve ever had at the beach. ⛈️🌦️

But I still enjoyed the same things I always do (just a little bit less time doing them). The salty sea air. Coffee in the morning in pajamas while watching the ocean. Ice cream. Mornings or afternoons on the beach. Walks on the beach. Swimming in a pool.

This year, we also watched the rain water build up in the streets, listened to thunder, and planned some indoor activities for the two days where it rained literally all day.

I’m happy to report that there were still a few moments like this though. ⬇️ Phew!

Added bonus? I left my laptop at home and barely thought about work, which is always a great way to recharge. ⚡

And remembered my book-themed week in my last edition? I had bought that pretty book I showed you, read it, and then exchanged it for a mystery novel at the beach house. This exchanging of books is a great beach house tradition because you get such an eclectic mix of paperbacks accumulating there, from people who came from all over and stayed before you in that house.

Back to this week, here’s what we’re talking about this:

Summer Edition #5: Summer in the City

  1. Feature: Why we love characters like Carrie and Emily, but can’t live their reality. Hint, it’s all about the money…

  2. Trailblazers Past & Present: This summer, we will highlight some of the women who have led the way in finance, or are currently doing so. This week, we look at Muriel Siebert, a rockstar on Wall Street who was the first woman to own a seat on the New York Stock Exchange.

  3. Journaling Prompt: Thinking about now always being “ready,” let’s take a few minutes to think about your answer.

  4. Feature: Products we love and will shout from mountains about

  5. Market Pulse: Our weekly snapshot of the S&P 500, AEX, Gold, Bitcoin

As always, share the love 💗 and forward this to the strong women in your life.

~ L 🍭

Feature #1

Champagne Budgets, Bread-and-Butter Salaries: How Carrie Bradshaw and Emily Cooper (Actually) Afford Their Closets…Or Do They?

I was too young for Sex and the City when it first came out, but I remember binging the episodes after a fellow traveler gave me the entire series off his hard drive. It was a goldmine of entertainment.

I mean, who didn't want the lifestyle of Carrie? A single writer with plenty of freedom in her schedule with amazing outfits and living in thrilling New York City.

Then, more recently, in pops Emily in Paris — same theme, different decade: young, single girl in a glamorous city, wearing daring outfits.

We love them, and maybe we try to recreate some of their lives in our own, like building an impressive shoe collection. But they are fiction. Carrie and Emily's lifestyles can't really exist without a huge trust fund behind them. I mean, come on, a stellar apartment in an expensive city, a huge closet where they never wear the same outfit twice?

Take Carrie's place. It's famously known that it was rent-controlled at $700 a month for a one-bedroom in a nice neighborhood. A steal, even in the show's own late-90s timeline, when a comparable apartment in that neighborhood would have gone for closer to $2,000 a month (based on a New York Daily News estimate).

Who knows how much Carrie actually made. In the first four seasons, she was a freelance writer, turning in one weekly column for a newspaper plus the occasional magazine assignment. She didn't land her first Vogue piece until season four, when the show implies that a 1,500-word essay would have paid her around $6,750 before tax. Nice chunk of change, but a necessity in NYC. Realistically, she was probably making somewhere around $50,000 a year until the Vogue pieces and book deal bumped that number up. But people famously don't get rich off one book…

And what did Carrie have to show for it? She spent $40,000 on her shoe collection, by her own admission on the show. She had almost no savings, carried credit card debt, and couldn't come up with the $30,000 she needed to buy back her own apartment from Aidan. No security net, no emergency fund. Just a closet she could theoretically sell off on Craigslist (or today, Vinted or Facebook Marketplace).

Even with a rent-controlled apartment, Carrie’s lifestyle was still extravagent. So either Carrie had a sugar daddy on the side, was drawing on an inheritance, or she was outrunning the bill collectors in her heels every day of her life. Which reality do you like for her?

Emily's lifestyle is more believable than Carrie's, but still idealized. At first, she's a corporate expat with her rent covered by the company. A genuinely great perk that I wish I had! On a salary of roughly $70,000–$90,000 (€60,800–€78,150 equivalent), with rent paid, she could reasonably afford the cafés, the trips, dinner out a few times a week, and some fashion purchases. Just not all the designer clothing she wears.

It's later, once Emily takes over her own rent after switching to the new marketing agency, that the math stops working. A comparable apartment today in that part of Paris would likely run €1,100–1,700 a month, depending on size and condition. It’s expensive even by early-2020s standards for someone that early in her career. Emily rarely mentions budgeting on the show, and her wardrobe of hundreds of designer outfits would have been impossible without serious savings or serious debt.

Dorothy knows Paris best, so here's her take on how realistic Emily's lifestyle actually is there:

❝

“It's this simple: it's not. The only realistic part of Emily in Paris are her bitchy French colleagues. Now, those are quite on point.”

~ Dorothy

So although we love these shows, they aren't realistic from a financial standpoint (or from a few other standpoints, honestly 😂). But would we even want to watch the "realistic" version? One where a person early in her career is scraping together money for every outfit or dinner out, repeating the same 20 pieces in her wardrobe?

Okay, those shows already exist actually, just under different names.

Girls (📍 New York), where the main character is a struggling writer supported by her parents in the beginning, living in Brooklyn rather than Manhattan, surrounded by friends with unstable jobs and unpaid internships.

Fleabag (📍 London), where financial instability and a failing business are central themes.

New Girl (📍 Los Angeles), with its roommate economics where the main character moves into a loft with three roommates because she can't afford to live alone.

Master of None (📍 New York), where the lead is an actor with a modest apartment and inconsistent work.

And those are just naming a few….

The difference comes down to the plot twist. ⬇️

  • Carrie Bradshaw: "How can I afford this lifestyle?" → plot twist: rent control

  • Emily Cooper: "How can I afford this lifestyle?" → plot twist: company pays

In the other shows, there's no twist. When viewers ask how the characters afford their lives, the honest answer is: they usually can't, and the show admits it.

But we don't always want to watch reality. We want to get caught up in the fantasy.

The trouble starts, though, when the fantasy gets carried into real life. (See what I did there? 😂)

Carrie and Emily's screens never show us the behind-the-scenes financial picture, and unfortunately, that's true of most people we know, too. We "Instagramize" our lives and our finances, and it's not helpful to anyone. It leads to overspending just to keep up with the picture we've put forward, and it doesn't do much to motivate the people around us, either.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Plentiful.money to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now

Reply

Avatar

or to participate